Print

THE POLITICIANS 50-YEAR RAIL FIASCO

WLC Booklet 1 180While Scotland, Wales and other English regions find favour with electrification and rail re-openings, the Home Counties south of London remain neglected by successive governments, despite having the busiest and most congested network.

This summer sees the 40th anniversary of the Wealden Line Campaign which coincided with the arrival of ‘Network SouthEast’, when British Rail last had effective and knowledgeable management with an eye to business. To mark the occasion, we’re now publishing online an edifying insight into the region’s struggle to reinstate two short links (just 7 miles and 5 miles) thus transforming rail operation by reconnecting Sussex, Kent and Surrey. It’s an appalling indictment of governmental failure.

Back in 1958 the ‘Oxted Lines Electrification Scheme’ was scheduled for completion by 1964, following immediately after BR’s highly-successful ‘Kent Coast Electrification Scheme’ accomplished in June 1961. The hugely-valuable Sussex project would have brought colossal benefits to its fast-growing towns, alongside transforming Southern Region operation and its services.

So why on earth didn’t it happen...?

Central to its sabotaging was Conservative Transport Minister Ernest Marples, who had both political and personal pecuniary interests in road construction. East Sussex County Council consequently found a powerful ally in Marples for their utterly maniacal dual carriageway slicing straight through the County Town of Lewes, including the Uckfield line. Despite huge public opposition, the all-powerful road lobby easily out-manoeuvred British Rail and were supported by Harold Wilson’s newly-elected Labour government. Rail managers bravely fought to retain Sussex’s network; however, Wilson’s Transport Minister Barbara Castle refused a one-off grant of £95,000 for BR’s alternative Uckfield-Lewes connection. Richard Marsh, her even more contemptible successor, swiftly approved closure solely to hasten Stage 1 of ESCC’s road scheme. Then, just three months after closing in 1969, ESCC abandoned Stages 2, 3, and 4 whereby this strategic railway was destroyed for nothing.

Accordingly, determined efforts to reopen this arterial line began, especially as the inadequacy of the adjacent and vulnerable Brighton Mainline became woefully apparent. With neither Labour nor Conservative governments willing to act, alongside an unceasingly hostile and duplicitous County Council, British Rail threw in the towel. After coming under increasing financial pressure from Margaret Thatcher’s government, BR then closed the 5-mile mainline from Sussex/Surrey into Tunbridge Wells, while simultaneously leaving the Uckfield line to deteriorate. Electrification was abandoned, followed by track rationalisation (partial singling). All this occurred despite the population increasing alongside widespread housing development.

Enter the Wealden Line Campaign in 1986, which recognised a tremendously valuable asset and not the liability our political incompetents had lumbered us with. In agreement was Chris Green, Director of newly-created Network SouthEast who saw the potential. He seriously challenged both East Sussex and Kent County Councils in 1987 to partner BR in funding reopening the Uckfield Line’s coastal connection (costing £6m). Typically, both councils refused, being interested only in road-building.

Meanwhile, the operational problems continued and famously made national newspaper headlines. We feature those uninterested ‘here today, gone tomorrow’ rail ministers who turned up for pre-election publicity stunts, as plea after plea fell on Whitehall’s deaf ears. It was a sorrowful time in many ways and quite literally a tragedy in 1994 when two passenger services disastrously crashed head-on at Cowden on a newly-singled stretch.

Parliamentary petitions, public meetings and displays followed, alongside disingenuous investigations into reopening with predetermined ‘no business case’ conclusions. Despite the arrival of ‘New Labour’ with Rail Minister Glenda Jackson MP grabbing newspaper headlines with statements saying ‘The Government is sympathetic to reopening the railway line between Lewes, Uckfield and Tunbridge Wells’ it went no further.

Tantalisingly, it came close to happening in 2000 when Connex UK Ltd submitted its 20-year franchise investment bid to create ‘The Wealden Main Line’ by reopening the moribund links with full electrification and 90mph trains. And they were serious, explaining this was theonly way of ever solving the persistent crises and overcrowding problems plaguing the beleaguered Brighton mainline.

In the run-up to the 2001 General Election, Sussex suddenly became the focus of political interest. Lib Dem President Charles Kennedy MP visited Uckfield, telling reporters he hoped that by the next EU elections he could continue his journey to Lewes by train. The Conservatives performed some green flag waving, backed-up by rail supporters urging ‘MEND THE GAP’. Green Party MEP Caroline Lucas put in appearances, whilst none other than Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott turned up at Crowborough to promote his ‘Strategic Rail Authority’. This proved to be nothing more than a publicity stunt as the loyal but deeply dismayed party worker discovered that evening.

Labour’s Strategic Rail Authority, which Richard Bowker later chaired, possessed no commercial acumen, let alone any vision or understanding of the South’s rail capacity problems. The SRA even proved less useful than the proverbial chocolate teapot. The same was true of GOSE (Government Office for the South East) which attempted, but failed, to delete safeguarding Lewes-Uckfield from its important-sounding ‘Draft Regional Transport Strategy’. Alongside other perfectly useless but hugely costly quangos such as SEERA (South East England Regional Assembly) and SEEDA (South East England Development Agency) which rejected the Wealden Line, it was ‘good riddance’ when they were all flushed away.

Then we had Transport Secretaries Stephen Byers and Alistair Darling who both dismissed re-opening Lewes-Uckfield, only to be humiliated when the campaign made known they had managed merely 12 miles of re-openings in 8 years after promising to ‘Reverse Beeching’.

Despite Rail Minister Tom Harris genuinely wanting the Wealden scheme to go ahead, the string-pulling civil servants at the Department for Transport (DfT) soon blocked that. The Conservatives then waded in with Theresa Villiers and Chris Grayling backing the scheme. Meanwhile, Prime Minister Gordon Brown denied any bias after the Wealden Line Campaign revealed schemes in Scotland and Wales were going ahead, whilst the paltry re-openings in England occurred only in Labour-held constituencies.

After East Sussex County Council committed their supreme act of treachery by deliberately contriving a ‘negative business case’ as the critical component of Network Rail’s 2008 Lewes-Uckfield Reinstatement Study, this council’s legacy moment was telling Parliament “Society as a whole would be worse off through reopening this line”. Because of the DfT’s ‘do nothing’ excuses, such as “the East Croydon bottleneck” as well as “trains would nowadays face the wrong way at Lewes”, the campaign launched Brighton Main Line 2 (BML2) in 2010. In dismissing BML2, the classic quote came from the DfT’s ‘Rail Operations Advisor’ who retorted “It is less easy to see how a business case as strong as the case for HS2 might be constructed to support the BML2 proposition”.  At that time (2013) HS2 costs had just risen from £34bn to £42bn....

The 3-phase BML2 (Sussex/Kent/London) scheme attracted serious interest in 2016 with Chancellor George Osborne pledging “a brighter future for the South Coast”. Despite him instigating another study, nothing happened because BML2 was viewed as ‘just’ a rail scheme, instead of a driver of economic investment across London, expanding Docklands and the wider South East. The Canary Wharf Group and the China Railway Engineering Corporation immediately saw BML2’s benefits (aka ‘Thameslink 2’) and its extraordinary potential. Predictably, the DfT refused any co-operation. Around that time and aware of the ever-struggling Brighton line, the Daily Mail commented: ‘This rail fiasco has a solution that’s staring us in the face’ not that the vacuous DfT cared. And you will see how satirical journal Private Eye displayed more cogency than successive governments as Sussex’s busy main line through Gatwick continued struggling on.

And so it continues. Despite Boris’s ‘Build Back Better’ and ‘Restoring Your Railway’, the region’s short moribund mainline rail links continue being ignored as more and more unsustainable housing piles in, the Brighton Line is literally falling to pieces and now the Transport Secretary adds even more pressure with her approval of Gatwick’s Second Runway.....


There is a supporting 32-page Booklet available to download and print which highlights the promotional literature the Wealden Line Campaign has produced over the last 40-years.